Why does my partner pull away the closer I get?

What if your partner's withdrawal isn't a refusal of closeness? What if it's the only way their system knows to stay intact? This episode maps the pursue-withdraw cycle from both sides: one person reaches, the other steps back, and the harder you try, the faster they retreat. It's not rejection. It's two different needs colliding on the same spectrum. The question isn't how to chase harder. It's how to stop chasing and start locating where you both actually stand.

Where We Are is a podcast about where you are, not what's wrong with you.

Hosted by Dr. Alon Aviram, psychotherapist. The show is built on the framework he uses in his practice: a way of finding where you're standing across the different parts of a life — the body, the self, relationships, groups, and meaning — and finding your way back to movement.

If something in this episode landed, you can go deeper at dralonaviram.com, where a free tool helps you find where you actually stand. The newsletter, The Shift, lives on Substack. And you can follow along on Instagram.

New episodes every week.

Drop the label.

Transcript

Copy Transcript Copied

SPEAKER_00 0:00

He texts to say he is thinking about her. She reads it and feels for a moment warm. Then she feels the familiar pull. She wants to see him. She says so. He says, yes, let's plan something. She says when let's say when. He says he needs to check his schedule. She feels the beginning of that old tightness and writes back something light so he won't notice. He doesn't notice. He sends a thumbs up emoji and goes back to whatever he was doing. Later that night she is looking at his profile on her phone. Not obsessively, just with the particular attention of someone trying to understand something. She thinks he loves me. I know he loves me. So why does it always feel like this? The gap between being loved and feeling close is one of the most disorienting places a person can stand. My name is Dr. Alon Aviram. I'm a psychotherapist, a couple therapist, and the founder of Humans. This is where we are, a podcast about what's actually happening between you. I want to tell you about a couple I'll call Sophie and Mark. They had been together for four years when they first came to see me. The referral note from their GP said, communication difficulties, that is how most of these arrive. Communication difficulties, as if the problem is the channel and not what is being sent down it. What Sophie described in our first session was a cycle so consistent she could almost predict it. She would feel close to Mark. She would reach toward him. A message, a request to spend time together, a question that asked for something real, and he would respond, but from a distance. Warmly, but briefly. Present but with the clear sense that he needed some weather around him. Some space between she would feel that distance and reach again. He would pull back a little further. She would feel that as something personal and reach harder. He would find reasons to be in another room. And then, when the tension was thick enough that both of them could feel it, he would soften. Come toward her. She would feel relieved. A few days later the whole thing would begin again. Mark's experience of the same cycle was entirely different. From his position, he felt a kind of mounting pressure he could not always name. The closeness felt like something being asked of him, something large, something he was not sure he had. When he stepped back, it was not because he did not want to be with her. It was because the pressure of being wanted that much was genuinely hard to hold. And when the pressure reduced, when she stopped reaching for a moment, he felt himself come back. Natural as breathing. The turning point in their work together came when I asked them both to describe what they thought the other person was experiencing during the cycle. Sophie thought Mark was withdrawing because she was too much, that she was asking for more than a reasonable person would ask for. Close enough to feel connected. Separate enough to feel like themselves. The trouble starts when two people's comfortable ranges don't overlap. If one person's natural range sits closer to the closeness end and the other person's natural range sits closer to the space end, there is a gap between those two ranges. And when the person who needs more closeness moves toward their partner to close that gap, the person who needs more space feels the move as pressure and steps back, which widens the gap, which causes the first person to reach more urgently, which causes the second person to step back further. Neither of them chose this. Neither of them is doing it out of cruelty. Both of them are doing exactly what feels necessary to stay in the range that feels like home. Here is what the person moving toward closeness is actually experiencing. They are not primarily seeking attention. They are seeking confirmation that the relationship is still there, that the other person is still close enough to be reached. When their partner steps back, that movement reads as more than distance. It reads as an answer to a question they did not quite know they were asking. The question being, are you still here? And the silence that follows each withdrawal answers. Maybe not quite. The reaching gets harder when the fear underneath it goes unnamed. And the fear is not weakness. The fear is what happens when someone who cares about you very much keeps moving away when you move toward them. That pattern writes on the nervous system. It becomes the thing that feels true. Here is what the person moving towards space is actually experiencing. The closeness is not unwanted, the person is not unwanted. But there is something in the intensity of being sought that creates pressure rather than warmth. When the person who loves them moves toward them with that particular quality of urgency, the whole relationship feels like it is waiting for them to perform something, to produce closeness on demand. And that is not what closeness feels like from the inside. Closeness comes when the pressure lifts. Space is not rejection. Space is the condition under which they can actually feel close again. Both people are trying to keep the relationship alive. The person reaching is trying to close the gap. The person stepping back is trying to relieve the pressure so they can return. They are working on the same problem from opposite sides. The tragedy is that each solution makes the other person's problem worse. The goal is not to find some middle ground and stay there. The goal is to make it possible to reach for each other again. For one person to learn that reaching once briefly and then waiting can get them further than reaching hard. For the other to learn that sending one signal before going quiet changes everything about how the quiet lands. I want to be careful with this, because the reaching is not a problem. The reaching is love expressed as urgency. What sometimes needs to change is not the desire for closeness, but the delivery. The urgency of it needs a different shape. Not because you are wrong to want what you want, because urgency reads as pressure, and pressure closes what you are trying to open. If you are the one who pulls back, you may not have understood until now how your withdrawal lands on the other side. It may feel neutral to you. Necessary, just the right amount of space. But for someone whose nervous system has learned that your stepping back might mean something larger, the withdrawal carries weight you did not put there. You are not responsible for that weight, but you are in a position to reduce it if you choose. Neither of you is the villain of this dynamic. You are both trying to stay close in the only way that feels possible from where you are standing. So the question I want to leave you with is this. What would it cost you to move one step in your partner's direction? Not all the way. One step. What would that actually feel like. If you are the one who reaches the next time you feel the pull, to send a second message, to ask again, to move toward when they have just moved back. Try this instead. Wait 20 minutes, set a timer if you need to, then reach once briefly. Not to test them, not to restart the cycle, just once, and then let it be. That pause changes the quality of the reach. It moves it from urgency to intention. And your partner can feel the difference. If you are the one who goes quiet, the next time you feel the pull towards space before you go silent, send one signal first. You do not need to explain yourself. You do not need to have a conversation, you do not have the capacity for right now. You just need to say something like, I need a little space, I'll be back. Those five words do something specific. They answer the question your partner is already silently asking. They close the gap between your withdrawal and abandonment. They make it possible for your partner to actually let you go because they know you are coming back. One pause, one sentence. She is looking at his profile on her phone. He loves her. She knows he loves her. The question was never whether the love was there. The question was whether the love had a way to travel between them. This cycle does not mean you chose wrong. It does not mean one of you is broken. It means you are standing at different, natural distances from each other, and you have both been doing the only thing that made sense from where you were. The distance between two people who love each other is not a wall, it is a space. And space is the one thing that can be moved across. I'll see you next time.